Not a misprint. Trying to read the 1001-page Schattenfroh, I felt like a deer in Lentz’s headlights. I looked into the source of the simile though I was familiar with the practice of nighttime deer-jacking from my rural Vermont upbringing. Deer eyes function best at night when the animals feed. An unexpected bright light freezes the deer in place as it “decides” what to do, where to go. My first deer reader episode occurred at page 72 of Schattenfroh when I encountered a 74-page, hand-written list of the thousands of people who died in the World War II bombing of Duren, Germany, Lentz’s hometown. I wondered if I owed it to the dead and to Lentz to read all the names. Other freezing episodes followed, though none as long as that one. But I continued to wonder what kind of rhetorical relationship existed between Lentz and me, the deer reader.
The first-person narrator of Schattenfroh, Nobody, says he’s not responsible for episodes that hinder the book’s meager continuity because he is the prisoner of Schattenfroh, a monstrous all-powerful being that forces the narrator to recall or experience or imagine various traumas--personal, cultural, and historical. Schattenfroh is not Lentz, not exactly, but some futuristic, technological force like maybe the Biggest Fucking Brother you might imagine. This control monster appears to be running an experiment, with Nobody as a subject, of cognitive manipulation. The writing of the book is one ongoing subject of the book being written while the reader is trying to read it. This “writing” is different, more like inputting, because the words are going directly from Nobody’s brain onto the pages with no typing required, though he did have to copy by hand that list of the dead.
Nobody addresses Schattenfroh and, occasionally, the reader. But this is not the “dear reader” of nineteenth-century fiction, a boon companion or faithful correspondent. Nobody has volunteered for the experiment in applied masochism. So, of course, has the deer reader of Schattenfroh. But neither volunteer could have predicted Schattenfroh’s cruelty—and continuity (one of the few continuities in the novel). Successful continual sadism, as Kafka’s The Castle showed, depends on the masochist’s continuing guilt, which may never be identified or exhausted. I tried to understand of what I was guilty. I examined my motives and terms. A masterpiece implies, not just the author’s mastery of information and form but also of the reader. A monsterpiece increases the maker’s power from master to monster. In choosing to investigate Schattenfroh as a possible monsterpiece, did I hope to be dominated and punished, the prisoner of a book? Was my Substack complicit in supporting cognitive control through literature? I presumed monsterpieces were an alternative to cultural domination, the order of the ordinary. Could Schattenfroh be a counter-monsterpiece, a demonstration of artistic mastery become horribly monstrous? Was the novel a thousand-page attack on itself, novelistic masochism? And did my guilt mean I had to finish the book? These are some of my questions whenever I felt like a deer reader.
One of the early root meanings of “monster” was “warning,” a meaning that continues in “remonstrate,” a word with aggressive negative connotations. If not itself, what is Schattenfroh’s remonstration warning against? Because Nobody volunteers to be Schattenfroh’s prisoner and subject (two meanings of that), I suspect the novel is an allegory of Nazi sadism and Hitler’s “willing executioners,” those citizens who claimed to be guiltless nobodies. Desperate for reasons to keep reading, I thought Schattenfroh could be a continuation of Gravity’s Rainbow. Like that book often set in Germany, Lentz’s traces monstrousness to what Pynchon called “Pernicious Pop” in his many avatars--Yahweh, popes, kings, fuhrers, proponents of the fatherland.
Nobody’s father is a tyrannical administrator who enjoys repeatedly beating Nobody at home, one of the first of many specific episodes of sadism and torture. Crucifixions abound with Jesus obeying his Father. Nobody’s mother and other women in the novel have little power over the fathers. Okay, I thought, maybe not so much like Pynchon as like Tokarczuk’s Books of Jacob, though it is a much more realistic assault on patriarchal religion, politics, and family life.
From early on, it’s obvious that of the novels considered on Monsterpieces Schattenfroh is the most thorough-going monstrosity. The narrator’s consciousness doesn’t stream, it streaks from one subject to the next, often without apparent cause or association. Facts and allusions and unknown languages and visual designs interrupt Nobody’s prison story. Beasts are invented, beastly acts reported. Chairs are animate and fight. Mystical or made-up languages are introduced. Nobody is forced to take a hundred-page excursion to his city back in the 17th century. Randomness and discontinuity rule. But what most discouraged me from proving that my masochism was heroic was an unhappy coincidence: Schattenfroh is a compendium of features that I resisted in other would-be monsterpices: the ghosts of Tom’s Crossing, the sci-fi of The Coast of Everything, the fantastical allegory of Solenoid. Ancient monsters were fabulous inventions. I was guilty of wanting my monsters and monsterpieces less imaginary, more probable.
Novels with a few strange dreams are sometimes described as “surreal.” Schattenfroh is blindingly, insistently, tediously surreal without the linguistic distortion that might make the narrator’s obsessional dream-like “inwardness” artistic and tolerable. It’s one thing to have the narcissistic narrator of The Tunnel write William Gass musical sentences, quite another thing to slog through the plodding sentences of Schattenfroh. The stylistic slush of Lentz (or his translator) makes the surreal Solenoid look like disciplined early Hemingway. In a prefatory note, Lentz connects his title with “schadenfreude.” I take no pleasure in reporting that Schattenfroh seems to me a grandiose artistic and rhetorical failure.
A character who is reading Schattenfroh says, “It would be best if we slammed the book shut.” I confess. About half way through, I did and didn’t go back to finish Schattenfroh. All of the previous judgments here are based on a mere 500 pages of deer reading. I confess and admit my limitations: the monsterpieces I finish and most respect are, it appears, extensions—excesstensions—of realistic fiction with characters trying to navigate monstrous—but current or historical--systems, preferably scientific and political. The novels’ alienation effects give me—a realistic character, I believe--pause to think about those systems. Lentz’s alienation is not an effect. It’s a high-beam attack, a succession of deer reader events, so I quit. As I did with Burroughs’ Naked Lunch, the surreal novel that I find the most similar to Schattenfroh. (I did eventually finish Naked Lunch, but it was much shorter than Schattenfroh and I then had much longer to live.)
But, dear reader, I know that Schattenfroh has been praised, and I can imagine a few courageous subscribers of Monsterpieces may want to venture out beyond my fuddy-duddy limitations, possibly even gain a sense of superiority over yours truly, monsterpiece man, so I went looking for a positive review I could respect and found one at this link:
https://clereviewofbooks.com/michael-lentz-gus-oconnor-schattenfroh/
The review is a remarkably detailed and learned explication of the novel as an attack on current German rightist revisionism of the German past, recent and distant. The author knows centuries of German history and mostly ignores the deer reader effects that finally stopped me halfway through Schattenfroh. When first reading the review, I felt further guilt that I had quit, but after some meditation--and with some possible rationalization--I came to believe that there is such a disabling imbalance between Lentz’s apparent earnestness and his deer reader methods that I had no responsibility to finish the novel. I would if I were being paid to read it, but this is an altruistic Substack. The subtitle of Schattenfroh is “A Requiem.” But what the author wanted readers to remember (and presumably understand) is so obscured by his self-aggrandizing performances of the surreal that he lost this reader. Or can I say, “even this reader,” who day and night scans the heavens for a “screaming comes across the sky,” for a monsterpiece he can praise.


I've just written a little intro (and conclusion) to that review--which I will post when Dzanc releases the novel. If you send me your email, I'll send you what I have at the moment.
That's, at its heart, the great disjoint I have with the work. And no, thank you for the kind words. And thank you also for all the writings incl. Your review of Women and Men I know you passed onto Joe. I'm the British writer trying to put something together to pay homage to that marvellous dreamwork that only becomes more prescient every day.